Home
avatar

麒麟剑

AdSense vs Monetag: Who Pays a Small Site First?

I run three small browser-game sites. One of them gets about a thousand visitors a day; the other two get under a hundred each. This month I put Google AdSense and Monetag on all three, at the same time, and watched which one actually starts paying first. This post is what I can verify so far — no income screenshots, no promised RPM, because there is nothing to screenshot yet.

The short answer

At roughly 1,000 daily visitors, Monetag is live and serving ads today. AdSense is still in review. That is the whole story so far: one network lets a small site start immediately, the other makes it wait in a queue. Everything else — which one pays more per thousand views — I cannot answer honestly yet, and this post will not pretend otherwise.

The traffic this conclusion stands on

These are real visitor counts from our self-hosted Plausible analytics, for complete days 28 Sep – 27 Oct 2026. Today (28 Oct) is excluded because the day is only half over.

Site30-day visitorsLast 7 daysDaily average (7d)
minigameshub.org38,6577,098~1,014
subwaysurf.org2,712539~77
sprunkigames.online1,246243~35

Three notes on the data, because the caveats are part of the result:

  • 16 Oct shows 0 visitors on all three sites. That is a tracking outage, not a real zero. It is excluded from the averages.
  • 27 Oct dipped to 614 visitors on minigameshub, down about 35% from 952 the day before. The other two sites were flat that day, and the site itself was up, so I am treating it as a real down day, not a measurement error. One day does not make a trend; I will watch whether it recovers.
  • Most of the traffic is not from the US. Earlier checks put US visitors at roughly 5–6% of the total; the bulk comes from India, Bangladesh and Indonesia. That matters, because ad rates vary sharply by country, and any revenue number from these sites says more about this traffic mix than about either network in general.

If your site gets 10,000 US visitors a day, this post is not about you. It is about the long tail: a few hundred to a thousand daily visitors, mostly outside the US, trying to earn the first dollars.

What each network is, and what it asks for

Google AdSense is Google’s display-ad network. You apply, Google reviews your site, and only after approval do ads serve. You need an ads.txt file declaring your publisher ID, and you do not get paid until your balance reaches $100. Payments then run monthly. There is no fixed traffic minimum, but the review is real: thin content, copied content or a site that looks unfinished can be rejected, and a rejection costs you weeks.

Monetag is an ad network built for exactly the publishers AdSense makes wait. There is no site review queue in the same sense: you create a zone, paste one script tag, and ads start serving. It offers formats AdSense does not — In-Page Push, vignette interstitials, popunders, SmartLinks — and its minimum payout is **5viaPayPal∗∗(perMonetag′sownhelpcenter),againstAdSense′s5 via PayPal** (per Monetag's own help center), against AdSense's100. Weekly payouts are available. The trade-off is control: Monetag’s formats are more intrusive by design, and you are choosing reach over polish.

Our timeline, verified

  • 19 Oct: Monetag In-Page Push goes live on minigameshub.org (zone 12080915).
  • 23 Oct: Full ad health check on all three sites. Monetag code confirmed in place on all three — vignette on subwaysurf.org (zone 12072254), MultiTag on sprunkigames.online (zone 299135) — and the AdSense publisher ID plus ads.txt verified on each domain.
  • 28 Oct (this morning): AdSense is still in review — about five and a half days since the sites were resubmitted. Last verified AdSense earnings figure, checked 22 Oct: $0.22 total across the three sites.

That $0.22 is the only AdSense revenue number I have, and it predates the resubmission. I am not going to dress it up as a run-rate.

The Monetag revenue question, answered honestly

Monetag dashboard figures for 19–28 Oct are not published here yet — they will be added once verified in the dashboard.

As this post stands, I have not published Monetag revenue figures, because I have not verified them in the Monetag dashboard. The code is live and serving; the earnings are whatever the dashboard says, and I will add the exact numbers in a follow-up once they are confirmed. Any article that quotes an RPM for this setup without showing the dashboard is guessing, and I would rather publish a gap than a guess.

What I can say from the setup side: Monetag took minutes per site and required no approval wait. That is a fact about process, not about money.

Honest comparison

Google AdSenseMonetag
ApprovalSite review, days to weeks; still pending for us after ~5.5 daysNo equivalent queue; zone live the same day
Time to first adOnly after approvalMinutes after pasting the tag
Minimum payout$100$5 (PayPal)
Payout rhythmMonthlyWeekly available
Traffic minimumNone fixedNone
Ad formatsDisplay, in-feed, in-articleIn-Page Push, vignette, popunder, SmartLink
User experienceLeast intrusiveMore intrusive — pick formats deliberately
Revenue visibility so far$0.22 total (22 Oct check), still in reviewCode live, dashboard figures not yet verified

One open question I am not settling in this post: our game sites run on Vercel’s Hobby plan, and Hobby’s terms restrict commercial use. Whether running ads counts against that is something I have seen argued both ways and have not verified against the primary terms text. It does not change the AdSense-vs-Monetag comparison, but it may change where the sites should live. That is a separate investigation.

What I would tell another small site

  1. Put Monetag on first. Not because it pays more — unproven — but because it pays something while AdSense reviews you, and its $5 payout threshold means the first payment is reachable in weeks, not months.
  2. Apply to AdSense in parallel and forget about it. The review runs on its own clock. Check once a week, not once a day.
  3. Choose the least intrusive Monetag format you can live with. We use In-Page Push on the main site and vignette on the fan site, and we skipped popunders. Aggressive formats trade tomorrow’s returning visitors for today’s impressions.
  4. Do not write an income tutorial before you have income. This post exists because the opposite — screenshots of other people’s dashboards passed off as a method — is most of what a small publisher finds when searching this question.

What happens next

When the Monetag dashboard figures are verified and AdSense finishes its review, I will update this post with the real numbers — impressions, earnings and the date each first payout actually lands. That follow-up is the post that can finally answer which network pays more. This one can only answer which one pays first, and so far the answer is Monetag, by default: it is the only one running.

出海 AdSense Monetag 网站变现 广告